I thought this was a great article showing how advanced we’ve become in science. I believe that if technology in science continues on this path we as scientist will be able to have a better understanding of humans and the hidden secrets of our mind. It's really cool and terrifying how much we can understand what's happening inside someones mind. I would like to find some court cases that involved fMRI.
Thursday, February 25, 2010
Notes #16-fMRI
fMRI
Note to readers…
There is a difference between a vegetative state and a coma. A coma is when a person is in a state of profound unconsciousness that can occur after head trauma, stroke, infection etc. A comatose person will sometimes wake up completely or go into a vegetative state-- “ a no man’s land of mental ambiguity”.
In a Vegetative State…
A person goes through cycles of sleeping and waking
They can open eyes
Swallow
Sometimes grunt or move limbs
Don’t normal respond in any organized way to acknowledge doctors or answer questions/commands
There a new way to help trapped victims- those in a vegetative state
New type of brain scanners functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI)
About fMRI
Detects signals related to change in flow of blood within the brain
In response to demands of active nerve cells
“Clever computer programs turn such measurements into those familiar pictures, looking like something you might see in a fancy restaurant in France -- a slice of brain in aspic decorated with red and yellow blobs.”
Red and Yellow blobs--- show the slow widespread changes in blood supply
After comes frenetic activity of nerve cells
Can’t tell exactly how the brain works--- does show what part of the brain is active while person sees, looks, hears, think remembers, etc.
One Test…
“The researchers trained one of their patients, a 29-year-old man whose brain was damaged in a car crash in 2003, to use his brain activity to reply to questions. Wandering indicated "no," tennis was "yes." The "blobs" reliably gave the correct answers to simple questions. Owen and Laureys have started similar tests on other patients and they think that perhaps one in six will be able to communicate via the scanner.”
In a few cases of people in vegetative state have “waking up” and said to have heard everything that was said and felt pain and itches without being able to respond to them.
An American company -- No Lie MRI-- has a “brain-scanning lie-detection test”
It bases diff. Patterns of blobs with telling the truth and lying
Many of the courts don’t want to use polygraph--- because of margin of error
The No Lie MRI-- has over 90% accuracy at the moment
May rise to 99%after the product development is complete.
I realize this excerpt is long but it’s really interesting…
Reading your thoughts
“In an experiment from my own lab, led by Dr. Tim Andrews, volunteers were scanned while they looked at photographs of human faces or man-made objects such as clocks and vases. Dutifully, the computer produced its brain scans with different blobs lighting up for the faces and the vases. Then Andrews and his colleagues showed the participants that famous visual illusion that looks like a pair of black faces staring at each other across a white gap. Every few seconds, the faces apparently disappear and the white gap in between looks like a large white chalice. The picture is, of course, ambiguous, and a confused brain flips between one perception and the other.”
“Next, Andrews gave the volunteers a pair of buttons to press, one to indicate that the pattern looked like faces, the other when it seemed to be a vase. He found that, by tracking the strength of the MRI signal in the brain region that had responded best to photos of real faces, he could predict with about 85 per cent reliability what the person was seeing, in the privacy of their conscious minds.”
The Big Question…
Will brain scans tell us what people can see
Whether they’re lying /what intentions are
May be able to foresee people with signs of psychopathy / terrorism / addiction
“Astronomy, from Copernicus on, has transformed our view of the place of the earth in the heavens. Darwin changed forever our view of the status of humanity. Neuroscience is likely to challenge our understanding of what it is to be a person.”